What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?


On our way back from a recent round of golf, Fritz and I were discussing the way most golfers evaluate golf courses. We've had this discussion before, and it inevitably gets around to my heartfelt conviction that trees do not enhance the "golfing experience".

Most golfers in North America assume that golf is not golf without tree-lined fairways. If I am not mistaken, this is a bias created by a century of golf course design compliments of a relatively small number of trend-setting designers. In Canada, Stanley Thompson was the main man. His course designs can be found across the country, and inevitably they feature lush green (soft) fairways lined with majestic trees.

Of course there are many reasons for this, both practical and esthetic. For starters, eastern North America has lots of trees, and just as important, it is impossible to replicate the sandy turf of Scotland or Ireland in other parts of the world that do not share the same climate.

Nevertheless it struck me as a bit odd when on a recent trip to Saskatchewan we found the same type of fairways in that relatively dry prairie climate as we have here in our much more humid environment in southern Ontario.

What we have seen in first half of the last century was a progression from the use of native grasses in a place like St. Andrews or Dornoch, Scotland to the use of highly manipulated hybrids like bentgrass in Ontario, where the climate can (more or less) support them (with constant watering, of course).

But rather than using native grasses in the prairie or semi-desert settings of the North American western plain, course designers in those regions seem to have imported the ideas developed in the east. Especially the use of trees and non-native grasses.

One course we played near Elbow, Saskatchewan had water lying around from the overnight watering. This was in spite of the recent rainy period in the area. And while the greens seemed to be holding up well, they were typically left quite long and shaggy so they could withstand the inevitable dry spell that was just around the corner.

Seems to me there should be native grasses that would do better than this. Of course I could be completely wrong...

My point is that golf course design in North America has often created synthetic environments that alienate the golfer from the native terrain and turf. Which gets me back to trees...

To my way of thinking, that trees should come into play during a round of golf seems an unfortunate departure from the original way the game was conceived. Once you play a bit of links golf you realize that the game was originally meant to be played by running the ball along the ground. Like curling, that other Scottish obsession, the game represents an attempt to control the way the ball (stone) interacts with the course (ice).

In the first 100 years or so of golf in North America we have tried to take this element out of the game by making sure that the ground remains soft, that the grass is as green and lush as possible, and that there are as many strategically placed trees as possible to get in the way of our drives and approach shots.

On the other hand, trees are an important part of the native landscape in many parts of North America, so I would be contradicting myself if I said they should not be part of a "natural" layout in eastern North American. I am not advocating the "denuding" of the landscape in order to create a pseudo links-like environment. But trees should remain strictly in the background as far as I am concerned. Thankfully, this seems to be the way golf course design has been moving for the last 15 years or so.

From Golf Stories at Internetgolfreview.com

Visit the article section at Internetgolfreview.com for more golf stories, articles and golf travel features.

Rick Hendershot is a writer, avid golfer creator of the Linknet Publishing Network. For online advertising opportunities, visit Linknet advertising options.







Related News



City solicits ideas for golf course's future - San Diego Union Tribune

City solicits ideas for golf course's future
San Diego Union Tribune, United States -42 minutes ago
By Lola Sherman All of those are ideas that have been put forward for the future of the Center City Golf Course, 75 prime acres of city-owned land just east ...

Marino leads AT&T National Golf Tournament at 5 Under Par - Voice of America

Voice of America

Marino leads AT&T National Golf Tournament at 5 Under Par
Voice of America -20 hours ago
By David Byrd American Steve Marino has a one-stroke lead over four other players after the first round of the AT&T National golf tournament. ...
Marino leads by one shot GOLFDetroit Free Press
Connecticut Rooters for MarinoHartford Courant
Local kid Marino leads Woods-less AT&T NationalThe Associated Press
Washington Post - Voice of America
all 356 news articles

Golf: Caddies feel pressure, share success - Salt Lake Tribune

Golf: Caddies feel pressure, share success
Salt Lake Tribune, United States -1 hour ago
Marco Dawson played his way into third place after three rounds of a Nationwide Tour golf event in Sandy, and his volunteer caddie was scared. ...

Golf: Ben Briscoe is the new top gun - WalesOnline

Washington Post

Golf: Ben Briscoe is the new top gun
WalesOnline, United Kingdom -Jul 4, 2008
BEN BRISCOE can rightly call himself the new shooting star of American golf. For the newly crowned Daisy Golf Classic champion doesn’t know whether he’s ...
Norman was the anti-Tiger during his reignLake County Record-Bee
Club Makers Help Golfers Get a GripWashington Post
Potential for a rough day at the AbbeyOakville Beaver
Voice of America - Orillia Packet & Times
all 423 news articles

Meriden mulls free golf for military members - Newsday

Meriden mulls free golf for military members
Newsday, NY -16 hours ago
Meriden officials are considering whether to waive greens fees for military personnel at its municipal golf course. A committee is reviewing a proposal to ...

Golf Capsules - USA Today

TVNZ

Golf Capsules
USA Today -7 hours ago
Anthony Kim, living up to his billing as the next young threat in golf, appeared poised to catch the leaders until a 1 1/2-hour storm delay that slowed his ...
UPDATE 1-Golf-Pernice fires 63 to grab share of AT&T leadReuters.uk
Golf Roundup Leaders Ahead by 3 at AT&TNew York Times
Rain Falls, Scores Drop At AT&TWashington Post
PGA Tour - Reuters.uk
all 259 news articles

Golf-Briton McDowell sets scorching pace at European Open - Reuters.uk

SuperSport

Golf-Briton McDowell sets scorching pace at European Open
Reuters.uk, UK -20 hours ago
By Tony Jimenez ASH, England, July 4 (Reuters) - Britain's Graeme McDowell set a scorching pace midway through the European Open second round at the London ...
Record-breaker Fisher reveals golf tournament pull-out debateAFP
Aussie Green makes the cut in LondonABC Online
McDowell on the move at The London Golf ClubEuropean Tour
BBC News - Independent
all 411 news articles


Women take center stage at golf events - MLive.com

Women take center stage at golf events
MLive.com, MI -Jul 2, 2008
by Greg Johnson | The Grand Rapids Press One of the biggest national names in women's golf will join a local rising star at an upcoming tournament in Grand ...
Nick Peet's Great 08 Challenge: Golf brings you down to earth with ...ic Liverpool
Las Vegas Golf deals and news that is cool and usefulPR-USA.net (press release)
North Texas e-News!North Texas e-News
Lake County News Chronicle - ESPN
all 1,267 news articles

50-year-old Joey Sindelar says he is loving his new golf life - The Canadian Press

The Money Times

50-year-old Joey Sindelar says he is loving his new golf life
The Canadian Press,  N.Y. -Jul 3, 2008
The prospect of playing the Champions Tour can have that effect on newcomers to pro golf's senior circuit. "It was probably less stressful because in our ...
Aches and pains too much for EaksPress & Sun-Bulletin
A strong fan following for Horseheads’ SindelarNews Item
Ozaki forced to speak about his lead at En-JoieThe Associated Press
United Press International - Scranton Times-Tribune
all 103 news articles

Houston area becoming a hotbed for young golf talent - Houston Chronicle

Houston area becoming a hotbed for young golf talent
Houston Chronicle, United States -3 hours ago
Lisa McCloskey, 17, who recently graduated a year early from Montgomery High School, is headed to Pepperdine on a golf scholarship after winning the Class ...
Golf NotebookTulsa World
all 3 news articles